Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
Table Of Content
What Is Online Defamation?
Online defamation refers to the act of making false and damaging statements about someone on the internet. This can occur via:
- Social media posts
- Online reviews
- Blog posts
- False news articles
- Forum discussions
- News comment sections
There are two primary types of defamation:
- Libel: Written defamation
- Slander: Spoken defamation
To qualify as defamation, the statement must be:
- False
- Communicated to a third party
- Harmful to the subject’s reputation
- Made without adequate research or truth verification
Understanding the difference between libel and slander is key, especially since online defamation typically falls under libel, which can have more lasting effects due to its permanence.
Civil vs. Criminal Defamation
Civil Defamation
Most defamation cases are civil matters, where the injured party sues the offender for monetary damages or injunctive relief (such as content removal). These lawsuits focus on compensation, not punishment. This process typically involves filing a complaint, going through discovery, and possibly settling before trial.
Criminal Defamation
Some states and countries treat defamation as a criminal offense, meaning the offender can face jail time, fines, or both. However, criminal defamation is rare in the United States due to First Amendment protections. When enforced, criminal penalties tend to be in response to extreme or malicious intent.
Is Defamation a Crime in the United States?
Federal Level
There is no federal criminal defamation law in the U.S. Defamation is largely governed by state law and is generally handled as a civil tort. The U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasized the importance of free speech and has placed significant hurdles in the way of criminal defamation enforcement.
State-Level Criminal Defamation Laws
Some U.S. states still have statutes criminalizing defamation, including:
- New York
- Minnesota
- Oklahoma
- Kansas
- Montana
While prosecutions are rare, they can happen in cases of extreme malice, repeated offenses, or when defamation results in severe consequences, such as threats or public safety issues.
Other states have repealed their criminal defamation laws, recognizing them as incompatible with constitutional rights or overly vague and subjective.
Real-World Cases Where Jail Time Was a Risk
Montana v. Helfrich (2017)
A man was charged under Montana’s criminal libel statute after posting false information about a police officer. The charges were later dropped, but the case drew national attention to the criminal implications of online speech.
Thailand: A Case of Criminal Defamation Abroad
In some countries like Thailand and the Philippines, criminal defamation charges are more common. A TripAdvisor reviewer in Thailand faced possible jail time for leaving a negative review that was deemed defamatory under local law.
🔗 Source: Human Rights Watch
United Kingdom
While defamation in the UK is primarily a civil issue today, historically, individuals have been prosecuted and even jailed under criminal libel statutes. These laws have largely been repealed, but the legal framework is stricter than the U.S. when it comes to online expression.
When Could Jail Time Be a Real Possibility?
While unlikely in most U.S. cases, you could face criminal penalties or jail time under these circumstances:
- Repeated offenses after cease-and-desist warnings
- Defamation that incites violence or harassment
- False statements involving national security or public safety
- Defamation involving obscenity, hate speech, or targeting protected groups
- Violating restraining or protection orders with defamatory content
Even if jail isn’t imposed, you could face:
- Fines and penalties
- Community service
- Probation or supervised release
In some states, criminal defamation laws can result in a permanent criminal record, affecting employment, housing, and other life aspects.
The Role of the First Amendment
The U.S. Constitution protects freedom of speech—but that protection has limits.
Not Protected by the First Amendment:
- False statements of fact
- Speech that causes harm
- Incitement to violence
- Obscenity
- Defamation
The line is drawn between opinion and fact. For example:
❌ “John Smith stole money from clients.” (Potentially defamatory)
✅ “I don’t trust John Smith’s business practices.” (Protected opinion)
Understanding these nuances can help individuals avoid defamation lawsuits while expressing their views online.
Penalties for Online Defamation
Civil Penalties
- Monetary compensation for damages (economic or emotional)
- Punitive damages in cases of malice
- Court orders to remove content or issue retractions
Criminal Penalties (Where Applicable)
- Fines up to $5,000 or more
- Jail sentences ranging from 90 days to 1 year
- Probation, community service, or other court-ordered sanctions
- Permanent criminal record (in states where applicable)
Can You Be Sued and Prosecuted at the Same Time?
Yes. In theory, you can be sued in civil court and charged criminally—although it’s rare in defamation cases.
Example Scenario:
- You post false and damaging content online.
- The victim sues for damages (civil suit).
- You violate a court order or repeat the offense.
- Prosecutors file criminal charges under applicable laws.
This dual action is more likely when the content includes threats or incites violence.
What to Do If You’re Accused of Online Defamation
- Stop Posting – Do not engage further. Additional posts can strengthen the other party’s claim.
- Consult a Lawyer – A qualified internet defamation attorney can assess your liability and guide your response.
- Remove Content – If appropriate, delete the offending content and issue an apology or clarification.
- Avoid Retaliation – Don’t respond with additional attacks, as this may escalate the situation.
Even if you believe your statements are true, the burden of proof falls on you in court.
How to Avoid Being Accused of Libel
Follow these best practices:
- Fact-check everything you post
- Clearly label statements as opinions
- Avoid name-calling or assigning criminal behavior
- Don’t rely on anonymity—IP addresses can be subpoenaed
- Use disclaimers on blog posts, reviews, and forum content
- Respect cease-and-desist letters—even if you disagree, it may avoid escalating the issue
Educating yourself on these basics can reduce your risk of legal trouble.
What Victims of Online Libel Can Do
If you’ve been defamed online:
- Document everything (screenshots, URLs, timestamps)
- Request content removal via the hosting platform
- Send a cease-and-desist letter
- File a lawsuit for damages
- Work with Defamation Defenders to remove or suppress harmful content online
✅ Contact Defamation Defenders for fast, confidential support.
Frequently Asked Questions
Not unless the review includes false claims that meet the standard for criminal defamation—which is rare in the U.S.
No. There are no federal criminal defamation laws in the U.S.
Civil involves monetary damages. Criminal may involve fines or jail time.
Be factual, label opinions clearly, and avoid attacking people personally.
While rare, minors can face civil or disciplinary consequences for harmful online speech.
Yes. With a court order or through SEO suppression strategies, harmful content can be deindexed or pushed down.
Possibly. A criminal record may show up in background checks and affect job prospects, especially in regulated industries.
Related Contents:
