Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
Online reviews shape consumer perception, influence buying behavior, and play a pivotal role in local SEO rankings. With businesses eager to protect their reputations, some turn to a controversial tactic known as review gating. While it may seem like a shortcut to higher ratings, the practice is not only risky—it can be illegal and damaging.
This guide explores everything business owners and marketing professionals need to know about review gating in 2025, including legal implications, platform rules, and safer, compliant alternatives. It also includes best practices, industry-specific concerns, platform enforcement policies, and strategies to manage your brand reputation without violating guidelines.
Table Of Content
What Is Review Gating?
Review gating is the practice of pre-screening customers to determine whether their feedback is likely to be positive before inviting them to leave a public review.
How It Works:
- A business sends a customer a survey.
- If the feedback is positive, they’re directed to leave a public review (Google, Yelp, Facebook, etc.).
- If the feedback is negative, the customer is redirected to a private complaint form or internal resolution process.
While intended to minimize negative reviews, this tactic creates an unbalanced and misleading public reputation and deprives consumers of a full spectrum of opinions.
Why Review Gating Is Risky in 2025
1. Violation of Platform Policies
Google, Yelp, and other major platforms have explicitly banned review gating.
- Google’s Review Policy prohibits “discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews.”
- Yelp warns against “review solicitation” and uses advanced algorithms to detect patterns of manipulation.
Violations can lead to:
- Removal of all reviews
- Public penalties or warning labels
- Account suspension or delisting
- Reduction in local search visibility
2. Legal Liability
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) classifies review gating as a deceptive practice under the FTC Act.
Businesses found guilty may face:
- Civil fines
- Cease and desist orders
- Class-action lawsuits
- Investigations into broader deceptive marketing practices
3. Damaged Credibility
If exposed, review gating erodes consumer trust. Customers often share screenshots or post about manipulated reviews, especially if they suspect censorship. Once trust is broken, it’s hard to rebuild.
4. Backfiring in Search Rankings
Search engines aim to surface trustworthy businesses. If review manipulation is detected, your business’s local SEO performance may drop, reducing visibility. Worse, your business may be flagged by watchdog blogs and review transparency organizations.
What Does the FTC Say About Review Gating?
The FTC’s guidelines on consumer reviews are clear:
“Companies must not prevent or discourage customers from submitting honest reviews, regardless of their sentiments.”
Under the Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA), businesses are prohibited from:
- Using contracts or policies to limit or penalize negative reviews
- Requesting feedback only from satisfied customers
- Conditioning incentives on the submission of only positive reviews
The FTC also expects transparency when endorsements, compensation, or review filters are used in marketing materials.
Examples of Review Gating (That Break the Rules)
Scenario 1: Conditional Survey Flow
“How did we do?” (Happy face / Sad face)
- Happy face leads to Google review form
- Sad face leads to private form
Scenario 2: Email Campaign Filters
Sending review requests only to customers who selected a high score in an internal feedback tool like NPS (Net Promoter Score).
Scenario 3: Incentivized Opt-In
Offering discounts, loyalty points, or gifts only after confirming a positive experience.
Scenario 4: Delaying Negative Invitations
Waiting several weeks to send review requests to unhappy customers while immediately prompting happy ones.
All of the above may violate FTC guidance and platform rules.
How to Collect Reviews Without Review Gating
There are legal and effective alternatives to generate positive, authentic feedback:
1. Ask Every Customer
Send out review invitations uniformly. Platforms like Google allow you to create a direct link to your review form. Embed it in:
- Email receipts
- SMS follow-ups
- In-store signage
- Chat transcripts
2. Use Neutral Language
Avoid phrases like “If you had a good experience…” Instead, say:
“Your honest feedback helps us improve. Would you mind leaving a review on [platform]?”
3. Use a Review Funnel — Legally
Design a feedback funnel that:
- Doesn’t filter based on sentiment
- Redirects all users to the same review page
- Offers an optional internal feedback link in parallel
4. Highlight Existing Positive Reviews
Use social proof on your website and marketing content, but never edit or censor quotes. Link back to the original review page to enhance credibility.
5. Respond to Negative Reviews Publicly
A well-written response can earn trust and sometimes even lead to the customer revising their rating. Never argue—acknowledge, apologize, and offer help.
How to Stay Compliant in 2025
Google My Business Best Practices
- Don’t pre-screen customers
- Never suppress or hide negative reviews
- Avoid review templates or scripting
- Follow their content and feedback guidelines
Yelp Best Practices
- Never ask for reviews—Yelp discourages all forms of solicitation
- Let reviews occur organically
- Use Yelp check-in features and badges to encourage engagement
Industry-Specific Guidelines
- Healthcare: Follow HIPAA when responding to reviews
- Finance: Comply with FINRA or SEC regulations
- Legal: Ensure confidentiality and avoid testimonial exaggerations
- Education: Avoid review incentives in school admissions or academic settings
Tools to Manage Reviews Legally
| Tool | Feature |
|---|---|
| Google Business | Custom review links, notifications |
| Trustpilot | Verified reviews, moderation dashboard |
| Yext | Listings management, review insights |
| BirdEye | Review monitoring, sentiment tracking |
| Grade.us | Multi-platform review funneling |
| RepCheckup | Automated review reminders (compliant) |
| Reputation Stack | Aggregates reviews, filters spam |
Defamation Defenders Can Help
If your business has been harmed by false reviews or defamation, Defamation Defenders offers a full suite of review protection and reputation repair services:
- Legal takedown of defamatory content
- Removal of fake reviews
- Reputation strategy consultation
- SEO content development to reinforce positive visibility
- Crisis communication support during review-based attacks
Learn more about our review management services or contact our team to begin restoring your online presence.
Frequently Asked Questions About Review Gating
While not always a criminal offense, it violates FTC and platform rules, which may result in civil penalties and reputational damage.
Yes, as long as all users still have equal access to leave public reviews regardless of internal sentiment.
FTC fines
Removal of all reviews
Suspension from platforms like Google or Yelp
Public exposure via press releases or legal notices
If you only send review invites to high scorers, yes. Ask all users to remain compliant.
Only if you’re not filtering based on experience or rating predictions.
Through behavior analysis, user flagging, unusual patterns, and AI monitoring tools designed to identify manipulation.
Related Contents:
