Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
Table Of Content
What Does “Public Domain” Mean for Mugshots?
In U.S. law, public domain refers to materials not protected by copyright and available for free use by anyone. However, this legal status is often misunderstood, especially when it comes to mugshots.
📌 Public record ≠ public domain
| Concept | Description |
|---|---|
| Public Domain | Free to use, modify, and redistribute without permission or legal liability |
| Public Record | Accessible under FOIA or state sunshine laws, but not freely reusable |
Many assume mugshots are public domain because they’re published by law enforcement. But public accessibility does not equal unrestricted usage rights.
Are Mugshots Considered Public Records?
In most U.S. states, mugshots are public records. This means that under transparency laws like the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) or equivalent state laws, they can be accessed by journalists, citizens, and in some cases, scraped by private companies.
However, just because they are accessible does not mean they are free to copy, sell, or monetize. Legal classification matters.
🧠 Tip: Public records are bound by privacy and usage laws depending on jurisdiction.
State-by-State Differences on Mugshot Access
Access to mugshots varies significantly across the U.S., depending on each state’s interpretation of public records and privacy laws.
States with Broad Access
- Florida: Under the Sunshine Law, mugshots are easily accessible by the public.
- Texas: Allows wide access to law enforcement records, including mugshots.
States with Restricted Access
- California: Mugshots may only be released if there’s a compelling public interest.
- New Jersey: Does not routinely release mugshots to the public.
- Illinois: Prohibits the use of mugshots for commercial purposes like removal-for-pay websites.
📚 For a breakdown of mugshot accessibility by state, see the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.
Can Mugshots Be Used Commercially?
Many commercial websites publish mugshots for profit. These sites scrape public law enforcement databases and post arrest photos—often with the intent of charging individuals for removal.
Notable Legislation:
- California Senate Bill 1027 (SB 1027): Prohibits charging fees for mugshot removal.
- Georgia Law: Requires mugshot sites to remove photos within 30 days if charges were dropped or dismissed.
- Oregon: Criminalizes demanding payment for mugshot removal.
The ethical and legal concerns of commercial mugshot publication are under scrutiny nationwide.
Federal vs. State Authority on Mugshots
There is no comprehensive federal law that governs mugshot publication. Therefore, state laws dictate access and removal rights.
Federal Agencies and Mugshots:
- FBI and U.S. Marshals generally do not release mugshots unless a fugitive is involved or there’s an urgent public threat.
- DOJ policy typically withholds mugshots from public access.
⚖️ The lack of uniform federal law creates confusion and inconsistency across jurisdictions.
The Personal Risks of Public Mugshots
Public mugshots can lead to severe reputational damage, even if the charges were dropped or dismissed. Once online, they may appear in search results indefinitely.
Common Consequences:
- Job denials or career damage
- Loss of customers or clients (for business owners)
- Social stigma and harassment
- Impact on housing applications
- Anxiety, depression, and emotional trauma
🧠 Reminder: Mugshots can appear in Google search, background check reports, and social media with alarming speed.
Legal Pushback Against Public Mugshots
Privacy advocates, legislators, and organizations like the ACLU are pushing for stronger legal protection against mugshot exploitation.
Legal Reforms Underway:
- Automatic removal after case dismissal
- Ban on pay-for-removal models
- Classifying mugshots as sensitive personal information
- Right to be forgotten legislation in select jurisdictions
📢 These changes aim to strike a balance between public interest and personal privacy rights.
Can You Remove Your Mugshot from the Internet?
Yes, but removal is rarely automatic. It requires persistent action, legal knowledge, or professional assistance.
Step-by-Step Mugshot Removal Guide:
- Identify Hosting Websites
Locate all sites publishing your mugshot, such as:- mugshots.com
- bustedmugshots.com
- local news outlets
- Check Expungement Eligibility
If your case was dismissed or expunged, you may have stronger legal rights. - Submit Removal Requests
Each site may have a contact form or instructions for requesting takedown. - Issue a Legal Takedown Notice
Send a cease-and-desist letter citing expungement, libel, or privacy violation laws. - Request Removal from Google
Use this form to request the removal of outdated or irrelevant content. - Hire Reputation Experts
Services like Defamation Defenders specialize in mugshot suppression, SEO cleanup, and legal enforcement. - Track and Monitor Reuploads
Use tools like Google Alerts, BrandYourself, or automated monitoring services to catch mugshot reappearances early. - Push Down Negative Results
Engage in active online reputation management: create content, register domains, and optimize positive assets.
Sample Cease-and-Desist Letter
Subject: Cease and Desist – Unauthorized Mugshot Publication
To Whom It May Concern,
You are hereby directed to remove all content and imagery associated with [Full Name], arrested on [Date], from your platform. The charges were expunged/dismissed and continued publication may violate [Applicable State/Federal Law].
Please confirm takedown within 10 business days to avoid legal escalation.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Contact Information] When to Hire a Mugshot Removal Expert
If you’ve followed the steps above and your mugshot still appears online, it’s time to seek professional help.
Defamation Defenders Services:
- Legal takedown assistance
- SEO suppression to bury arrest artickes and mugshots
- Content creation for reputation repair
- Real-time monitoring for reuploads
- Strategic removal campaigns
🔒 Click here to request confidential help
Expunged or Dismissed Cases: Your Rights
If your arrest record was expunged or sealed, you may have:
- The right to demand removal from commercial databases
- Legal standing under Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
- Leverage under false light privacy laws
- Support from state-level expungement statutes
📘 For more on expungement laws, check Nolo’s Guide.
Related Posts from Our Blog That You Might Like:
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
No. Public domain and public records are different. Most mugshots are public records but not free to reuse or redistribute without restriction.
In many states, yes—especially if you’ve been cleared of charges or if the site is charging removal fees.
Potentially forever unless removed voluntarily by the site or forced through legal means.
Be cautious. Many removal services are scams. Use reputable sources like Defamation Defenders.
Yes. Most employers use online search and background checks during the hiring process.
International takedown requests may be more complex. Consult legal experts experienced with cross-border defamation and privacy law.
No. Google can remove the search result snippet, but not the original file unless the hosting site complies.
